Report Shows That Union Contractors Add Value, Reduce Project Costs, Mitigate Project Risks

October 28, 2022

A new report by Independent Project Analysis (IPA), an independent international construction project engineering and research firm, shows that union mechanical contractors were 15% more productive than non-union contractors, with a more than 40% reduction in risks of cost and schedule overruns. It further reveals that the total cost of union projects was 4% less than non-union projects. The report is based on an analysis of 1,550 capital projects on industrial facilities across the United States over the past 20 years.

The United Association of Union Plumbers and Pipefitters (UA) and Mechanical Contractors Association of America (MCAA) joint press release on the topic provides additional details and project background.

The report was included as an attachment to MCAA’s comments on FAR Case 2022-003, Federal Acquisition Regulation: Use of Project Labor Agreements (PLAs) for Federal Construction Projects. Read those comments here.

You can download the full report, including methodology, here.

Related Articles
As part of its ongoing commitment to protecting your livelihood and setting the stage for a bright future, MCAA has secured the services of Longbow Public Policy Group to advise our MCAA Government Affairs Committee (GAC). GAC Chair, Jim Gaffney will be passing along information relative to our industry on a regular basis.…
Congratulations to the first IPM graduates of 2026! After two weeks of intensive and immersive education, the students of Classes 95 and 96 have joined the ranks of the more than 2,750+ IPM alumni from MCAA member companies across the country.…
When properly organized and operated, Industry Improvement Funds (IIFs) are effective, efficient, and equitable tools for strengthening market conditions, competitiveness, and labor and employment initiatives across the mechanical contracting industry nationwide. MCAA’s Industry Improvement Fund Operations Guide offers mechanical contractors, association leaders, and fund administrators practical, legally grounded guidance on organizing, administering, and maximizing the impact of IIFs—helping them manage funds with confidence and clarity. It’s just one of MCAA’s educational resources that are free to MCAA members as a benefit of membership.…
Twenty-nine MCAA Student Chapters submitted a proposal for the MCAA Water Park project. Congratulations to the Final Four and Merit Award teams. Final Four teams will present their proposals on the afternoon of Tuesday, March 17th on the main stage at MCAA26 in Phoenix, AZ.…
Load More...